FAQs: Controlled Burning & Vegetation Response on Blanket Bog Peatland
- Rob Beeson
- 1 day ago
- 3 min read
These frequently asked questions are taken from the scientific paper: Post-burning responses by vegetation on blanket peat sites on a Scottish grouse moor
How does prescribed burning affect vegetation composition on blanket bogs?
Does prescribed burning damage sensitive plant species like Sphagnum?
Is prescribed burning always detrimental to peatlands and carbon storage?
What are some of the challenges in studying the long-term effects of prescribed burning?
Does prescribed burning impact the overall plant diversity on moorland?
What is the purpose of prescribed burning on moorland?
Prescribed burning, typically in small patches, is a traditional management practice on moorland, particularly on sites managed for red grouse shooting. The primary aim is to regenerate heather shoots, which are more nutritious and thought to support higher breeding densities of red grouse. This creates a mosaic of vegetation heights and structures, which also benefits some ground-nesting birds.
How does prescribed burning affect vegetation composition on blanket bogs?
Studies indicate that prescribed burning influences the relative abundance of different plant species. Heather cover, vegetation height, and biomass tend to increase over time following a burn. Conversely, cotton grass cover initially increases after a fire but decreases as heather regrows. Sphagnum moss cover can be significantly higher in areas burned eight to ten years prior compared to unburned areas, suggesting that burning at regular intervals can favor Sphagnum by reducing competition from heather.
What role do Sphagnum mosses play in peatlands?
Sphagnum mosses are key peat-forming vegetation in blanket bogs. They contribute significantly to the structure and function of these ecosystems, including their ability to store carbon, maintain water quality and retention, and act as a natural buffer to reduce flood risk. The study highlights that prescribed burning can promote Sphagnum cover by managing heather dominance.
Does prescribed burning damage sensitive plant species like Sphagnum?
While high temperatures during fires can damage Sphagnum, low-intensity or 'cool' fires can reduce heather cover without destroying the Sphagnum layer. Some Sphagnum species, like S. capillifolium which was dominant in this study, are considered resilient to low-to-moderate fire severities. The photosynthetic capacity of surviving Sphagnum can recover relatively quickly after a burn.
Is prescribed burning always detrimental to peatlands and carbon storage?
Burning is a controversial issue with claims of it contributing to peatland degradation and reducing carbon storage. However, studies also suggest that areas subject to managed burning can still accumulate carbon. Furthermore, prescribed burning at appropriate temporal intervals can benefit peat-forming vegetation like Sphagnum, which plays a vital role in carbon storage.
How can prescribed burning influence wildfire risk?
Prescribed management fires can help reduce wildfire risk and severity by reducing the overall vegetation biomass, thus limiting fuel loads. They can also create fire breaks, potentially disrupting the spread of larger, unmanageable wildfires.
What are some of the challenges in studying the long-term effects of prescribed burning?
Studying the long-term effects of prescribed burning using historical burn data can be challenging due to the non-random distribution of past fires. This can make it difficult to control for other factors that may influence vegetation response, such as water table depth, weather conditions immediately after burning, or historical grazing levels. Therefore, long-term experimental studies with randomized control and burn treatments are recommended for more conclusive findings.
Does prescribed burning impact the overall plant diversity on moorland?
While the study observed changes in the relative abundance of specific plant species like heather and Sphagnum, there was no overall significant effect of burn age on vascular plant or moss diversity indices over the ten-year post-burn interval studied. However, another study observing a longer timeframe (60 years) did report changes in plant diversity, suggesting that the timescale of observation is important when assessing the impact of burning on diversity.
Keep Updated With Our FREE Newsletter
📧 Keep updated on all moorland issues - sign up for our regular free newsletter.