top of page

Defra Defers on Wildfire Risk Behind Burning Rules: Parliamentary Questions, 9–15 November 2026

3 hours ago
3 min read
Wildfire

Quick summary


  • Defra has not said whether it assessed wildfire risk before the 2025 burning regulations took effect.

  • Defra said its September answer did not claim repeated burning increases wildfire frequency. No evidence followed.

  • Defra defends the regulations on carbon grounds yet says wildfire emissions are difficult to quantify.

  • Commons groups should be able to apply for Higher Tier later this year, Defra says.

Defra has not said whether it assessed wildfire risk before the 2025 burning regulations came into force. Asked directly, Defra minister Jenny Riddell-Carpenter said the answer would come in the Government's formal response to the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (EFRA) Committee. She gave no date.


That was one of eight moorland-related written answers published between 9 and 15 November.


The Burning Regulations and Wildfire Risk


Jenny Riddell-Carpenter answered five questions on the Heather and Grass etc. Burning (England) (Amendment) Regulations 2025, all on 11 November. The Moorland Association's position is that well-managed burning reduces fuel load and wildfire risk. None of the five answers addressed that question.


  • Kevin Hollinrake (Conservative, Thirsk and Malton) asked for the evidence that repeated controlled burns increase wildfire frequency. Defra's 14 September answer to Question 27487, the minister replied, "did not claim that repeated controlled burns increase the frequency of wildfire."

  • She then made a different point. Repeated burning, she said, changes how these habitats are structured and function, and damaged peatlands are "more susceptible to the effects of wildfire." She called peatland restoration an effective long-term answer. No source was given for that claim.

  • Hollinrake also asked when ministers approved the regulations. Approval "was given on 8 September 2025 when it was signed," after ministers considered consultation responses, including those of the National Fire Chiefs' Council (NFCC) and fire and rescue services.

  • Bob Blackman (Conservative, Harrow East) asked whether the NFCC's advice on the restrictions was considered for the regulations' Explanatory Memorandum. He got the same consultation line. Officials and the minister engaged with the NFCC after it responded.

  • Hollinrake's third question cited paragraph 175 of the EFRA Committee's report, A burning issue: managing wildfire risk. Did Defra assess the regulations' wildfire impact before they took effect? We await the Committee response.


The carbon case came from Aphra Brandreth (Conservative, Chester South and Eddisbury), who asked what backed the Explanatory Memorandum's claim that the regulations would help cut emissions.


"Degraded peatlands emit the carbon they once stored," the minister said. She cited Natural England report NEER155, which drew on 102 new studies and concluded that repeated burning risks permanently altering peatland species composition and hydrology.


Emissions from wildfires were covered in one sentence. They depend on many factors, she said, and are difficult to quantify.


The Wildfire Summit and the 2027 Season


Sir Alec Shelbrooke (Conservative, Wetherby and Easingwold) asked whether changes to vegetation management policy were considered for the wildfire summit's action programme.


The minister pointed instead to support already on offer: "Defra recognises that effective land management is critical to increase resilience to wildfire." Scheme options cover scrub removal, and the summit added money for fire breaks and fire ponds.


Ben Obese-Jecty (Conservative, Huntingdon) asked the housing ministry to define the 2027 wildfire season. Minister Florence Eshalomi gave no dates. "Wildfires can occur at any time of year, with peaks typically in spring and summer," she said on 10 November.


Common Land


Aphra Brandreth also asked when farmers on common land will get access to Environmental Land Management schemes, including the Sustainable Farming Incentive (SFI). Defra minister Stephen Morgan replied on 13 November: "We expect commons groups to be able to apply for common land in Countryside Stewardship Higher Tier later this year".


That leaves about six weeks. Applications will go through a process the Rural Payments Agency is still building. SFI has no timetable: Defra "will continue to test and refine the application process before considering any wider rollout, including implications for the Sustainable Farming Incentive."


Coming Up


These were tabled this week and are awaiting an answer.



Key Takeaway


Defra still has not said whether it assessed wildfire risk before restricting burning. Land managers carry that risk every spring, and the Committee response must answer it.


 
 

Get our FREE Newsletter

Receive the latest news and advice from the Moorland Association:

You may change your mind any time. For more information, see our Privacy Policy.

  • Facebook
  • X
  • Instagram
  • Youtube
  • LinkedIn

Company Registered in England and Wales: 8977402

bottom of page