OEP Finds Defra and Natural England Failing Legal Duties to Birds

Quick summary
The OEP found Defra and Natural England failing their legal duties to protect wild birds in England.
Some SPA recommendations to designate or extend protected sites have gone unanswered since 2001.
Curlews on grouse moor edges raised nearly four times as many chicks as at sites without predator control.
Defra should track chicks reaching flying age alongside breeding pairs and keep lawful predator control where it helps.
The Office for Environmental Protection (OEP) said on 18 November 2026 that the Environment Secretary and Natural England were failing to meet their legal duties to protect wild birds in England. Defra’s latest figures show that 55% of the breeding bird species assessed in England declined between 2019 and 2024. The equivalent UK figure was 45%.
In a study across Britain’s uplands, curlew pairs at sites on the edges of managed grouse moors raised nearly four times as many chicks to flying age as pairs at similar sites without routine predator control.
What the OEP found
Special Protection Areas (SPAs) safeguard places where vulnerable birds breed, spend the winter or stop during migration. The OEP found that the Environment Secretary had failed to act on recommendations to designate new sites, extend existing ones and add qualifying species to their protections. Some of those recommendations go back to 2001.
The regulator also found that Natural England had taken insufficient action to maintain or restore wild bird populations and had failed to review whether enough suitable habitat was available. It welcomed Natural England’s plans for new designations and its work with Defra on species recovery.
Defra and Natural England have two months to reply to the OEP’s decision notices. Each must say whether it accepts the findings and what action it intends to take. The OEP can take the case to court if it cannot resolve the failures by agreement.
More breeding waders and more curlew chicks
Between 2016 and 2018, David Baines and colleagues surveyed 18 pairs of moorland and adjoining farmland sites in northern England, North Wales and Scotland. They paired grouse moor sites where gamekeepers routinely controlled predators with similar sites where there was no routine control.
Grouse moor sites supported 8.5 breeding wader pairs per square kilometre, about twice the 4.1 at comparison sites.
Curlews fledged an estimated 1.05 chicks per pair at grouse moor sites and 0.27 at comparison sites.
Golden plover were recorded at half the grouse moor sites and about one in five comparison sites.
Lapwing density was also about twice as high at grouse moor sites. The researchers found no clear difference in snipe density. Curlew breeding success was higher where there were fewer signs of foxes and lower counts of birds in the crow family. Predator control was one of several differences in management between the sites.
A 2026 study estimated 1,764 breeding pairs of curlew in Upper Teesdale, about 3% of the UK total. This North Pennines landscape includes grouse moors and low-intensity farmland, with the most curlews per square kilometre on rough grazing and grassy moorland.
Repeat surveys about a decade apart suggest local numbers held steady. The British Trust for Ornithology estimates that UK breeding curlew numbers fell by 51% between 1995 and 2024.
What helps waders breed
An eight-year experiment in Northumberland tested lawful predator control while keeping habitat conditions consistent. Where control reduced fox and crow numbers, breeding success was three times as high on average across five species, including curlew, lapwing and golden plover. For these three waders, researchers measured the share of pairs that raised at least one chick to flying age.
A 2025 modelling study projected declines in curlew and golden plover if grouse moor management ended while the land stayed as moorland. Climate and land cover explained more of the differences in bird numbers across upland Britain than the study’s measure of grouse moor management did.
Put breeding success in recovery plans
Defra should set a timetable for acting on the outstanding SPA recommendations. It should work with Natural England, farmers and gamekeepers to maintain nesting and feeding habitat and retain lawful predator control where local evidence shows it helps birds breed.
A protected site can attract many breeding pairs and still produce too few chicks to sustain its population. Defra and Natural England should track how many chicks reach flying age alongside counts of breeding pairs. Those figures should guide decisions on which upland management practices to keep or change.




