top of page

Why Won’t the RSPB Share Its Hen Harrier Tag Data?

3h
5 min read
Hen harrier

Quick summary


  • Further improvements in outcomes since April 2025 – see ‘The results’  below.

  • The MA wants a single comprehensive shared register of every UK-tagged hen harrier, but the RSPB withholds its data.

  • A lost signal alone cannot prove a crime: failed harnesses, dirt on the solar panel, vegetation and other causes can all silence tags.

  • Woodland predation, natural mortality and oversized mapping squares are often overlooked when hen harrier losses are reported.

The share of hen harrier tracking outcomes for all monitored birds (commencing 2002) classed RED (final transmission from a driven grouse moor, or illegal killing reported) has fallen to 42%, down from 47% in April 2025.


That is the latest finding from the Moorland Association register, which lists all 278 hen harriers tagged (both radio and satellite) since 2002 that appear in Natural England’s published tracking data, up to and including the August 2026 update.


Anyone can inspect any entry, including the organisations that disagree with our conclusions.



One register for every tag


The MA wants a single comprehensive register of every hen harrier tagged in the UK, curated by a panel chaired by Natural England (NE). The panel would bring in the Hawk & Owl Trust, the MA, Raptor Persecution UK (RPUK) and the RSPB, and ideally the police National Wildlife Crime Unit as well.


The RSPB and RPUK have full access to the MA and NE data, but the RSPB will not let the MA see its own tag data.


We asked the RSPB for its tag data on 25 July 2024 and followed up on 30 July. At the RSPB’s request we filled in its Request for Data form and sent it back on 31 July. The answer came on 8 August 2024 from the RSPB’s Investigations Intelligence Manager, who described the data as highly sensitive and wrote that “on review we are unable to provide the data requested on this occasion.”


With the RSPB’s birds included, the register could pass 500 entries – it holds 278 today. The RSPB has not explained why it will not agree to a single shared record, and we would still like to know.


Critics have said our commentary is not peer reviewed. To the best of our knowledge, the bird crime reporting by the RSPB and RPUK is not peer reviewed either.


If the RSPB or RPUK dispute an entry, we would welcome a meeting and will correct anything shown to be wrong.


Why tags fall silent


NE’s “Missing Fate Unknown” category covers two very different groups of birds. NE says the first is “Satellite tagged birds that were recorded after the battery ran out or transmissions had stopped”. Those birds were alive after their tags went quiet.


The second group died where their tags could not transmit. The tags run on solar power, on a variable cycle often 10 hours on and 48 hours off, so a bird that dies during an off period may be many kilometres from its last recorded fix. A tag lying face-down, or buried in long vegetation, may never send another signal.


Most of the satellite tags used to date were made by Microwave Telemetry Inc. Its Executive President, Russell Howey, told the MA in an email dated 29 May 2024 that the tags are reliable, subject to their condition and circumstances. He listed what can stop one working:


  • a failed harness

  • dirt on the solar panel, or abrasion damage to it

  • deep vegetation cutting off the light

  • an antenna that is damaged or touching the ground

  • being close to a building, a cliff or another tag


He put battery life at around three years in good conditions. Any of these problems can silence a tag, which is why a lost signal on its own cannot prove a crime.


Woodland and natural predation


Thirty-nine of the 278 entries have no published final location. Of the remaining 239, 130 (54%) sent their last signal from close to a significant block of woodland, meaning at least 1 km² (247 acres) of continuous or closely linked woodland. Of those, 105 were within 3 km (1.8 miles) and a further 25 within 5 km (3 miles).


The MA’s last brood management licence already took predation risk into account. It required release sites to have no known badger setts within 2 km (1.2 miles) of the release pen, and a note to the licence advised avoiding known goshawk territories.


NE’s own notes on individual birds point to natural predation, including what is known as intraguild predation, where one predator kills another that hunts the same prey.


The woodland belt from west of the M74 to Kielder, north of the A69, accounts for 28 final transmissions, or 12% of the 239. Predation in and around woodland is under-studied, and its link with these final transmissions needs proper investigation.


Natural mortality


MA modelling shows how hard a hen harrier’s first year is. It follows a cohort of 10 chicks through four scenarios. First-year mortality runs from 40% to 70%, leaving between 3 and 6 birds alive at one year old, and each scenario then applies 25% mortality a year. By year 10, fewer than one of the original 10 survives in every scenario. We are taking expert advice on which scenario fits best.


Natural mortality estimates draw partly on studies in Orkney, which has no driven grouse shooting. Orkney also has no foxes, badgers or weasels, had no stoats until recently and has little woodland, so the pressures on young birds there are very different from those on the mainland.


In the MA’s view, survival claims rarely account for vole numbers or the weather, though both factors help decide how many juveniles come through their first year.


Mapping scale


Every final location in the register is given as a six-figure grid reference, which pinpoints a 100 m × 100 m square (1 hectare – 2.47 acres). We plot each one on OS Landranger and Explorer maps.


Announcements to the media usually use much larger squares. A 10 km square covers 100 km² (24,700 acres – 38 square miles) and measures 14 km (8.78 miles) corner to corner. A 20 km square covers 400 km² (98,842 acres – 154 square miles) and measures 28 km (17.5 miles) corner to corner.


Squares that size can pull distant estates into reports of unrelated incidents. The register’s Map One shows a 10 km square whose edge just takes in the eastern suburbs of Skipton. A buzzard shot there with an air rifle would be reported in the same square as estates and moors many miles away that had nothing to do with it.


The results


Each entry gets a colour from NE’s data. GREEN means the final transmission came from land away from driven grouse moors, or a natural death was proven. RED means the final transmission came from land used for driven grouse shooting, or illegal killing was reported. Inconclusive cases are split 50/50 between the two – and birds still transmitting count as GREEN.


So the RED total includes every final transmission on grouse moor land, whatever caused the tag to stop, with illegal killing being reported for 7 of the 278 birds.


  • April 2025 (260 entries): 53% GREEN – 47% RED

  • September 2026 (278 entries): 58% GREEN – 42% RED

  • Most recent five years, 2022–2026 (61 entries): 66% GREEN – 34% RED

  • Radio tags only (99 entries): 52% GREEN – 48% RED

  • Satellite tags only (179 entries): 62% GREEN – 38% RED


GREEN has increased from 53% to 58% since April 2025. The newer satellite tags also give a more favourable (and it must be assumed more accurate) result than the older radio tags, at 62% GREEN against 38% RED – and over the last five years the GREEN share reaches 66%.


Why this matters


The MA has opened all 278 entries to scrutiny, and land managers deserve to be judged on one complete register with the RSPB’s birds also included.



 
 

Get our FREE Newsletter

Receive the latest news and advice from the Moorland Association:

You may change your mind any time. For more information, see our Privacy Policy.

  • Facebook
  • X
  • Instagram
  • Youtube
  • LinkedIn

Company Registered in England and Wales: 8977402

bottom of page